Had my Thursday writing class, though, and throughout the afternoon continued to reshape the opening of my novel, making it sharper, I hope, with fewer extraneous details.
I had already ordered “American Dirt” when I read this damning review.
After all, Oprah had recommended it and the last two of her picks that I read were really good (Colson Whitehead and Ta Nehisi-Coates — both historic fiction set in slave times). I will want to read “American Dirt,” just like I wanted to read “The Help.” To see for myself.
But! Since some of the outrage has to do with disproportionate advances and super hyped promotion for white authors (and not just cultural appropriation, savior stances, violence porn, and lack of credulity in the work itself), I took note and ordered a novel by a Mexican writer. I will read it first.
Wow that review was beyond scathing, wasn’t it?
Two people I know found its snide tone off putting. I thought her rage was clarifying. Subsequent review I read was more balanced (LA Times I think) and focused on promotion and advance.
That first image is so wonderful in its colors and power! I loved The Help 🙂
BTW~ I heard the author interviewed on NPR this morning and thought of you and this post. She sounded very reasonable and…well, at least people are talking, yes?
One week later and her book tour has been cancelled because of death threats. I can understand the critiques and the outrage and it’s too bad it’s come to this.
these are strange days indeed
Who knew we’d see such dark times?
did you like the book?
I ordered it on amazon and it hasn’t arrived yet.